Home › Most argued over

Idea Stock Exchange

Most argued over

The beliefs with the most reasons for and against, counted at every level beneath them. This measures how much has been argued, not how well; the best argued are on Best beliefs. What this list means, how it is counted, and why it is tracked →

Ranked by reasons for and against

#ClaimTruthConfReasons
1We should tax property by the value of the land itself, independent of what is or is not built on it. Belief0.5038%44
2Barring members of Congress and the president from owning or trading individual stocks would reduce the use of public office for private gain. Belief0.5067%39
3Letting Congress overturn a presidential pardon by a two-thirds vote of both chambers would reduce the use of the pardon power for private gain. Belief0.5054%37
4Barring the president and members of Congress from giving any official government function to a family member would reduce the use of public office for private gain. Belief0.5053%33
5Requiring the president and members of Congress to publish their tax returns would reduce the use of public office for private gain. Belief0.5053%32
6We should make America the dominant energy producer in the world, by far. Belief0.5036%19
7The United States should stop outsourcing and become a manufacturing superpower. Belief0.5036%18
8Workers should get tax cuts, and tips should not be taxed as income. Belief0.5036%17
9America should grow to one billion citizens. Belief0.5037%16
10Public office should not be usable for private gain. Belief0.5040%16
11We should defend the freedom of religion and the freedom from religion. Belief0.5036%16
12We should defend our fundamental freedoms, including freedom of speech. Belief0.5035%14
13America should adopt a comprehensive scorecard that measures national progress across human development, economic vitality, environmental health, and social cohesion, not just GDP. Belief0.5036%12
14A good end does not justify using means that would otherwise be wrong. Belief0.5033%11
15Caitlin Clark's popularity owes more to her play than to her being white. Belief0.5039%11
16Caitlin Clark is the main reason WNBA attendance and television ratings rose sharply in 2024 and 2025. Belief0.5041%10
17Leaving Caitlin Clark off the 2024 United States Olympic basketball team was the right call. Belief0.5041%10
18Public policy should be driven by data and measurable outcomes rather than by ideology. Belief0.5036%10
19We should support and strengthen democracy to restore the voter's voice. Belief0.5036%10
20Opposing players have targeted Caitlin Clark with harder and more frequent physical play than other rookies and stars receive. Belief0.5041%9
21Representative civic juries should be convened, online and in person, to deliberate on key legislation. Belief0.5035%9
22We cannot stand by while cultures are subjected to genocide, as exemplified by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Belief0.5036%9
23America should encourage legal immigration. Belief0.5035%8
24America should invest in energy research. Belief0.5035%8
25Ranked-choice voting produces better electoral outcomes than plurality voting. Belief0.5033%8
26A strong America is good for the planet. Belief0.5033%7
27America should end illegal immigration. Belief0.5035%7
28America should streamline the system to recruit and retain highly skilled workers. Belief0.5036%7
29America should strengthen its global leadership by modeling a strong, functioning democracy at home. Belief0.5035%7
30A company generally serves the public best when it focuses on making a profit for its owners within the law. Belief0.5032%6
31A country should generally keep its military spending high in peacetime rather than cutting it once threats seem to fade. Belief0.5032%6
32A country should protect its key manufacturing industries with tariffs even when imports are cheaper. Belief0.5032%6
33A dictionary should generally refuse to list a widespread misuse of a word as a legitimate meaning until careful writers have accepted it. Belief0.5032%6
34A four-year college degree is still worth its cost for most students. Belief0.5032%6
35A news outlet that publishes a false and damaging claim about anyone, including a public figure, should generally have to pay damages if it failed to take reasonable care to check the claim. Belief0.5032%6
36A newspaper that can no longer pay its own way should generally be allowed to close rather than be kept alive with public money or special rules. Belief0.5032%6
37A person's choices matter more than their circumstances in how their life turns out. Belief0.5032%6
38A photograph's worth clearly rests more on what it truthfully shows than on the photographer's artistry. Belief0.5032%6
39A single government-run health insurance program covering everyone would generally deliver better care at lower cost than a system of competing private insurers. Belief0.5032%6
40Adding automation to critical systems tends to create new kinds of failure that are harder to catch than the ones it removes. Belief0.5032%6
41Adults should feel free to build their family life around their own happiness rather than around tradition. Belief0.5032%6
42Adults should generally be allowed to buy common prescription drugs from a pharmacist without a doctor's visit. Belief0.5032%6
43Adults who borrowed for college generally should repay their loans rather than pass the cost to taxpayers who did not attend. Belief0.5032%6
44Any registered voter should be able to vote by mail without giving a reason. Belief0.5032%6
45Archaeologists should generally excavate important sites now rather than leave them in the ground for future generations. Belief0.5032%6
46Banks that are too big to fail should be broken up. Belief0.5032%6
47Banning the sale of new gasoline cars by a fixed date is generally a mistake. Belief0.5032%6
48Building a new, larger particle collider is clearly worth its cost for what it could reveal. Belief0.5032%6
49California should generally override local zoning rules to force far more housing to be built. Belief0.5032%6
50Canceling a large share of existing student loan debt would do more good than harm. Belief0.5032%6
51Charging drivers a fee to enter the most crowded part of Manhattan is the right policy. Belief0.5032%6
52Children generally do best when raised by two married parents. Belief0.5032%6
53Cities should generally redesign streets to slow cars down, even when that lengthens drive times. Belief0.5032%6
54Cities that spend public money on stadiums for professional teams generally get back less than they put in. Belief0.5032%6
55Claims that apes and parrots understand language generally reflect human wishful thinking rather than real ability. Belief0.5032%6
56Comedians should generally be able to joke about any subject without losing work over the offense a joke causes. Belief0.5032%6
57Communities are generally better off when most people belong to a religious congregation. Belief0.5032%6
58Companies should be banned from putting forced arbitration clauses in consumer contracts. Belief0.5032%6
59Companies should need a person's clear permission before collecting their data for advertising. Belief0.5032%6
60Competition in educational opportunities, such as charter schools and school vouchers, makes traditional public schools better. Belief0.5033%6
61Dictionaries should generally record how people actually use words rather than rule on which uses are correct. Belief0.5032%6
62Doctors should generally follow standardized treatment guidelines rather than rely on their own judgment. Belief0.5032%6
63Employers should generally be free to fire workers without having to show a reason, as long as the firing is not discriminatory. Belief0.5032%6
64Fish clearly feel pain in a way that matters, not just a reflex to avoid harm. Belief0.5032%6
65For most people, ordinary daily activity such as walking delivers most of the health benefit of exercise, and formal workouts add little. Belief0.5032%6
66For most people, staying able-bodied into old age requires planned strength training that gets harder over time, because everyday activity alone is unlikely to preserve the muscle and bone that keep people independent. Belief0.5032%6
67Free trade with other countries makes ordinary people in a country better off overall, even when some industries lose. Belief0.5032%6
68Governments should generally fund efforts to keep endangered minority languages alive. Belief0.5032%6
69Governments should generally provide limited public funding to local newspapers so that local government keeps getting covered. Belief0.5032%6
70Governments should generally require proven childhood vaccines for school attendance. Belief0.5032%6
71Governments should generally set a maximum price for medicines that are still under patent. Belief0.5032%6
72Governments should not hold back the spread of AI in workplaces in order to protect existing jobs. Belief0.5032%6
73Governments should put protecting the environment ahead of economic growth when the two conflict. Belief0.5032%6
74Heavy digital editing generally does not make a photograph any less of a photograph. Belief0.5032%6
75Historians generally should not judge people of the past by today's moral standards. Belief0.5032%6
76Houston is right to go without traditional citywide zoning. Belief0.5032%6
77Human activity is clearly the main cause of the warming seen over the past century. Belief0.5032%6
78Hunting is generally good for wildlife conservation. Belief0.5032%6
79In wealthy countries, most adults who stay poor do so mainly because of their own choices about school, work, and family, not because the chance to escape was closed to them. Belief0.5032%6
80Internet providers should generally be barred by law from speeding up, slowing down or charging extra for particular websites and services. Belief0.5032%6
81Japan should keep immigration low even as its population shrinks. Belief0.5032%6
82Jokes that mock people for their race, religion, disability or sex do real harm and deserve public pushback. Belief0.5032%6
83Journalists should generally have a legal right to refuse to reveal a confidential source's identity, except where a court finds the name is needed to prevent serious harm. Belief0.5032%6
84Judges should be allowed to keep suspects they consider dangerous in jail before trial, even when those suspects could afford bail. Belief0.5032%6
85Judging teachers partly by their students' test results generally makes schools better. Belief0.5032%6
86Large companies should be required by law to give their workers seats on their boards. Belief0.5032%6
87Law enforcement should be able to read encrypted messages when it has a warrant. Belief0.5032%6
88Laws that require people to prove their age before using social media do more harm than good. Belief0.5032%6
89Letting public education money follow each student to the school their family chooses clearly improves education for the families who need it most. Belief0.5032%6
90Long prison sentences generally do little to reduce crime compared with raising the odds of being caught. Belief0.5032%6
91Longer prison sentences generally make communities safer. Belief0.5032%6
92Most people probably need not cut back on their vacation flights for the climate's sake. Belief0.5032%6
93Most people with depression or anxiety would clearly benefit from professional treatment rather than handling it on their own. Belief0.5032%6
94Most people's character is set by their upbringing and changes little in adulthood. Belief0.5032%6
95Most working authors are better off self-publishing than signing with a traditional publisher. Belief0.5032%6
96Most young people would be better served by trade training or an apprenticeship than by a four-year degree. Belief0.5032%6
97Museums should generally return human remains and sacred objects to the communities descended from the people they belonged to or who made them. Belief0.5032%6
98New movies should generally open in theaters for a period before they reach streaming services. Belief0.5032%6
99Ordinary people are generally better served when social media platforms show news posts without labeling, fact-checking, or removing them than when platforms do those things. Belief0.5032%6
100Paid random rewards in video games should be regulated the way gambling is. Belief0.5032%6
101Patients with serious illness should generally be free to try unproven treatments with their own money. Belief0.5032%6
102People should generally pay for routine medical care out of their own pockets and buy private insurance only to cover large, unexpected expenses. Belief0.5032%6
103Philosophy generally makes no real progress on its big questions. Belief0.5032%6
104Philosophy should generally be taught in high school alongside math and science. Belief0.5032%6
105Phone makers should be allowed to require that every app on their devices pass through an app store they review. Belief0.5032%6
106Police departments should spend more of their effort preventing crime than making arrests. Belief0.5032%6
107Popular destinations should generally cap the number of tourists they admit. Belief0.5032%6
108Popular genre fiction such as romance, crime and fantasy generally deserves the same critical respect as literary fiction. Belief0.5032%6
109Popular national parks should generally require timed-entry reservations. Belief0.5032%6
110Public decisions should generally rest on measured statistics rather than on personal experience and anecdote. Belief0.5032%6
111Publicly funded television news is generally not worth the cost now that viewers have countless free sources. Belief0.5032%6
112Quoting a famous person generally adds little to whether a claim is true. Belief0.5032%6
113Radio remains an essential news source during emergencies and for people who lack reliable internet access. Belief0.5032%6
114Raising the minimum wage generally helps low-paid workers more than it hurts them. Belief0.5032%6
115Reference works should generally refuse to print a quotation whose original source cannot be found. Belief0.5032%6
116Religious beliefs should almost never be the basis for deciding what the law should be. Belief0.5032%6
117Routine cancer screening of healthy adults with no symptoms generally does more harm than good. Belief0.5032%6
118Rules that bar ordinary people from buying investments that are open to the wealthy do more harm than good. Belief0.5032%6
119Sales taxes on everyday goods should be lower than they are today. Belief0.5032%6
120Schools in a country with one dominant language should teach mainly in that language rather than in students' home languages. Belief0.5032%6
121Schools should generally require students to read the classic works of literature rather than let them choose their own books. Belief0.5032%6
122Scientists and agencies who publish regional and local climate forecasts generally present them with more confidence than the climate models behind them have earned. Belief0.5032%6
123Scotland would be better off as an independent country. Belief0.5032%6
124Self-driving cars can clearly be made safer than human drivers on ordinary roads. Belief0.5032%6
125Sending public money to private and charter schools generally weakens the neighborhood schools that most children still attend. Belief0.5032%6
126Simple life exists on many planets in our galaxy. Belief0.5032%6
127Social media platforms should be required to pay news publishers for the articles that draw users into their feeds. Belief0.5032%6
128Statistics quoted in public debate tend to mislead more often than they inform. Belief0.5032%6
129Statues honoring historical figures who did serious wrongs should generally be removed from public squares. Belief0.5032%6
130Streaming has clearly done more good than harm for musicians by letting anyone reach a worldwide audience without a record label. Belief0.5032%6
131Streaming services generally pay working musicians too little to make a living from recorded music. Belief0.5032%6
132String theory has clearly failed to earn the central place it holds in physics. Belief0.5032%6
133Studios should let viewers choose to watch new movies at home on the same day they open in theaters. Belief0.5032%6
134Talk radio generally does more to drive its listeners apart from people who disagree with them than to inform them. Belief0.5032%6
135Tariffs on imported goods generally cost a country's consumers more than they save its workers. Belief0.5032%6
136Teachers generally do their best work when they control what and how they teach rather than following a set script. Belief0.5032%6
137Teaching children to build toughness and tolerate discomfort does more for their mental health than teaching them to monitor and talk about their feelings. Belief0.5032%6
138Technology tends to solve environmental problems better than restrictions on how people live. Belief0.5032%6
139Technology-building intelligent life has arisen on very few worlds in our galaxy besides Earth. Belief0.5032%6
140Television channels that present opinion shows in the style of a newscast should be required to label those shows as opinion on screen. Belief0.5032%6
141Texas should connect its separate electric grid to the national grids rather than keeping it apart. Belief0.5032%6
142The United Kingdom should rejoin the European single market. Belief0.5032%6
143The highest-earning households should pay a larger share of their income in taxes than they do today. Belief0.5032%6
144The legislature, not the executive alone, should generally have to approve any sustained military action abroad. Belief0.5032%6
145The seven states that share the Colorado River should let the federal government decide how to divide its shrinking water supply rather than try to negotiate a deal among themselves. Belief0.5032%6
146Traditional publishers still generally produce better books for readers than self-publishing does. Belief0.5032%6
147Training AI on copyrighted work without permission should be against the law. Belief0.5032%6
148Violent content in video games generally needs no government rules beyond the age ratings the game industry already puts on its products. Belief0.5032%6
149Voters should generally be required to show government-issued photo identification before casting a ballot. Belief0.5032%6
150Warning labels and disclosure rules do little to change how people buy and add cost without much benefit. Belief0.5032%6
151We should give our outdated weapons to democratic allies trying to defend their territory. Belief0.5032%6
152When a government pays to have software built for public services, its source code should, by default, be made public for anyone to read. Belief0.5032%6
153Where a person ends up in life is shaped more by the family and neighborhood they were born into than by their own choices. Belief0.5032%6
154Youth leagues should not offer tackle football to children below high school age. Belief0.5032%6
155America should reform its immigration laws. Belief0.5036%5
156Congressional term limits would reduce corruption and improve legislative quality. Belief0.5036%5
157True freedom requires balancing individual liberty with personal responsibility and active civic engagement. Belief0.5016%4
158We should keep men out of women's sports. Belief0.5030%3
159Students in failing schools should be able to exercise school choice. Belief0.5013%2
160Homelessness, crime, and low mass transit use in cities like Denver are holding back urban density. Belief0.5012%1
161We should defend the United States Constitution. Belief0.5034%1

Built from revision 42c8344, committed 2026-10-04. 2173 pages. Every number above is computed from the two tables in that revision, so a reader who fetches it gets these numbers and not different ones.